I was constipated on a high protein bulk. So I tested 5 fiber snacks.

I was hitting my protein and I was constipated, so I ate one kind of fiber snack each week and tracked every morning.

By Colin R.5 minute read

The five snacks I tested

I left trivia night one round early. I told my teammates I had an early morning, which wasn't true. I was constipated and so bloated that my jeans were tight across my stomach, and I hadn't gone to the bathroom since Sunday.

My team lost that last round by two points without me, which bothered me more than the bloating did. On the train home I scrolled back through my food log to find out what I was doing wrong.

I'm bulking, so I'm hitting my protein every day with eggs, beef, yogurt, and two shakes. When I looked for plants, the only one I'd logged all week was rice.

The next morning was squat day, and my stomach was so full that I couldn't tighten my belt or take a deep breath under the barbell. I quit after two sets.

I already track my coffee and my sleep in spreadsheets, so that weekend I started a third one. I bought five fiber snacks and ate one kind each week, keeping my meals and my lifting the same. Every morning I logged whether I'd gone to the bathroom.

My girlfriend Dana saw the column header and told me to keep the laptop off the dinner table.

The five snacks I tested

  1. 1.
    Floura Variety Pack Fiber Bars

    They are best for mornings when I'm backed up.

    See it on Amazon
  2. 2.
    Fiome Fiber Bites

    They are best for a morning routine I won't change.

    See it on Amazon
  3. 3.
    Metamucil Fiber Thins

    They are best for an afternoon at my desk.

    See it on Amazon
  4. 4.
    ChocZero Dark Chocolate Almond Bark

    They are best for long drives when I'd buy candy.

    See it on Amazon
  5. 5.
    ChocZero Caramel Crunch 4 Pack

    They are best for dessert on game night.

    See it on Amazon

1.Floura Variety Pack Fiber Bars

The fruit bars gave me my best week of the test.

Front of the Floura Variety Pack Fiber Bars packageNutrition details for Floura Variety Pack Fiber Bars

I started with the fruit bars because their label showed more fiber than any of the other four. The bars are soft, so I could eat one on the train every morning with my tablet in my other hand.

Nothing happened on Monday, but on Tuesday I went to the bathroom before I left for the train, and then every morning after that. By squat day the bloating was gone, and I got through all my sets with the belt on.

The flavors are odd, but mango cardamom is good enough that I ate those first. I didn't enjoy the blueberry matcha because I could taste the tea and not the blueberry, so Dana got mine.

The bars squash easily, which annoyed me when my laptop flattened one in my backpack and it stuck to the wrapper. I ate that one with a spoon from the office kitchen.

See Floura Variety Pack Fiber Bars on Amazon

2.Fiome Fiber Bites

The small bites worked almost every morning with no effort.

Front of the Fiome Fiber Bites packageNutrition details for Fiome Fiber Bites

For week two I picked the small soft bites, because I could eat one while I make coffee. I weigh the beans and time the pour every morning anyway. Dana finds the coffee routine ridiculous, but it meant I had nothing new to remember.

I was regular most mornings that week. The directions on the bag are one bite a day and two at most, so I had mine while the kettle heated. I kept the bag next to the coffee scale and never missed a day.

The bites are tiny, and one bite isn't much food when I'm on a bulk. I was still hungry afterward, so I ate my eggs early all week. Peanut butter is the flavor I'd buy again.

See Fiome Fiber Bites on Amazon

3.Metamucil Fiber Thins

The cinnamon cookies gave me something crunchy at my desk.

Front of the Metamucil Fiber Thins packageNutrition details for Metamucil Fiber Thins

In week three I wanted an afternoon snack for work, so I opened the fiber cookies. My dad has kept this brand above his fridge since I was a kid, and it was strange to have my own box at 28.

They're thin crunchy cookies that come two to a packet, and I had a packet with tea at my desk every afternoon. Cinnamon spice is the best flavor, and apple crisp is second.

The cookies do crumble, and on the second day I got crumbs in my keyboard. I went to the bathroom on fewer mornings than in the bite week.

Almost everything in my food log is soft, so these cookies were the only crunchy thing I ate all week. By Wednesday I was looking forward to the afternoon packet.

That Sunday I brought a packet to dinner at my parents' house, and when my dad spotted it on the counter he got his own box down. We had them with coffee after dinner, and he was very happy about it.

See Metamucil Fiber Thins on Amazon

4.ChocZero Dark Chocolate Almond Bark

The almond chocolate squares replaced my gas station candy.

Front of the ChocZero Dark Chocolate Almond Bark packageNutrition details for ChocZero Dark Chocolate Almond Bark

Dana's cousin got married six hours away during week four, so I spent two days of the test sitting in a car. It bugged me, because I'd planned to change only the snack each week.

I was backed up for most of that week, including both driving days. I can't tell how much of that was the chocolate and how much was the sitting.

I picked the almond chocolate squares for the drive because every square has its own wrapper, and I filled the cup holder before we left. It's dark chocolate with almonds and sea salt and no sugar, and it's good. On a normal road trip I buy a bag of candy at the first gas stop and finish it by the second. On this trip I had two squares at each stop and didn't buy any candy.

See ChocZero Dark Chocolate Almond Bark on Amazon

5.ChocZero Caramel Crunch 4 Pack

The caramel squares helped the least and tasted the best.

Front of the ChocZero Caramel Crunch 4 Pack packageNutrition details for ChocZero Caramel Crunch 4 Pack

Dana and I host a board game night once a month, and that month's night was in week five. I'd saved the caramel chocolate squares for it, because they're a dessert.

Each one is a small wrapped square of dark chocolate with caramel flavor and crunchy bits, and there's no sugar in them. They were my favorite thing to eat in the whole test, and I had two after dinner every night. I usually eat cereal out of the box around 9, but that week I didn't open the box once.

On game night I put the rest out in a bowl, and our friends emptied it before the first game was over. Marcus enjoyed them enough to type the name into his phone. That left me with none for Sunday, which irritated me.

The test was about the bathroom, though, and this was my worst week of the five. As a dessert, they were the best of the five.

See ChocZero Caramel Crunch 4 Pack on Amazon

Since the test ended I've kept buying two of the five. I reordered the fruit bars and I eat one on the train on weekdays, and the bites stay next to the coffee scale for weekends. My bulk meals haven't changed.

I still log every morning, and on most mornings I go to the bathroom. Squat days are back to normal, and I finish all my sets with the belt on. Dana still thinks the spreadsheet is gross, but she asked me to put the caramel squares out at the next game night.

Last Thursday I went back to trivia night, and this time I wasn't bloated, so I stayed through the last round. We finished third, and nobody asked why I'd left early in September.